The info I've read on the electric ones tells me they aren't powerful enough to do any real heating. The glow plugs they use just aen't rated high enough to warm te volume of fuel we're talking about. Have wondered about the peugout water heated fuel filter though but they don't do much till th engine is warm.
What money would I save though.
I would suggest those who say they arent hot enough stick their pinkies on one when its working :thumb2
In all seriousness it depends on the unit you have, how many of them and where theyre placed.
You can definitely feel the difference on the hose after the heater on mine and its a relatively small unit and as a non scientific measure the oil coming out of the feed to the pump is noticeably thinner & warmer. Of course December onwards will be the telling time but another heater at £23 before the filter could provide interesting results or even change the existing one for a double or triple glow plug set up ? I dont know.
The counter argument to the opinions youve read is that if you leave the heater on when you're running on diesel you will (and I quote) "frazzle the derv" to a point where its "past its best" so there must be sufficient heat there.
I recently spoke to a chemist (after an indirect contact with a fuels chemist in the states) employed at a refinery near us who's opinion was any heat is better than none so long as it doesn't cause the fuel to get too hot & break down. The warmer it is the better it will atomise and therefore run better.
Theres also great debate as to whether the water heated ones are any good. The opinion on running them long term seems to be they're not as good as the electric ones. The reason is the level of heat is less controllable and more variable.
With all this opinion and counter opinion I can only say I don't know conclusively. My opinion is that its a case of proof of the pudding and all that and mine is just fine :thumb2 but still with a weather eye to points like Col made.
As far as dosh saving goes. I presume you're reclaiming the vat? I and the majority of the population cant of course so that puts bio if i could find it still way more expensive than svo which is vat free .
How much would you save? depends on how committed to purchase volumes . An IBC ( as one enterprising member on here has done
) has the potential for massive savings and theres no regs regarding storage and transportation even if you got your old tanker filled up. Buying by the litre at Asda would cost more than diesel and be a pain.